CSM Vision Implementation Audit - 2026-06-20

Scope

Reviewed against:

`docs/cm_csm_adac_aspec_product_vision.md`
`docs/CSM_Macro_Vision_Explainer.html`
`docs/TWO_FILE_CONVERTER_SETTINGS_ARCHITECTURE.md`
`docs/MACRO_ARCHITECTURE_AND_PLAN.md`
Prototype shell: `C:\Users\a.almouhajer\Downloads\CSM_Apply_Profile_UI_Shell_v2_prefilled_extracted`
CSM Graphify manifest: `graphify-out/CSM_GRAPH_MANIFEST.md`

Built / Verified

One fixed production macro remains the target: `exports/CSM_Apply_Profile.4dm`.
Macro compiles cleanly to `exports/CSM_Apply_Profile.4do`.
Static 12d call audit is clean: 91 official calls, 0 unknown calls, 0 policy warnings.
UI shell uses real `GridCtrl_Box` review tables.
Source model is a `Source_Box`.
Client is a `Choice_Box`, prefilled to Vida for test/default workflow.
Run, group, and attribute action buttons are horizontal groups.
The macro has a "Go to element" path using `Get_focus_cells`, hidden model/element uid grid columns, `Get_cell`, `Get_element`, `Highlight_add_string`, and `View_fit`.
Project/runtime values are driven from `csm_field_input_spec.csv` and saved back to `CSM_client_subprofile.txt`.
Output Window XML capture remains wired through `Save_output_window_to_XML`.
CSM Graphify was rebuilt after changes.
Export audit passed: 82 PASS, 0 FAIL, 0 MISSING, 2 SKIPPED.
Full test suite passed: 1039 passed.

Fixed In This Loop

Added `REFERENCE_POINT_A` runtime key support to the fixed macro.
Added point-reference dispatch for `reference_geometry` candidates using nearest readable reference point vertices.
Added explicit skip evidence when `REFERENCE_POINT_A` has no readable point vertices.
Added explicit skip evidence for unknown fallback candidate kinds instead of collapsing them to generic missing fallback evidence.
Added Output Window logging for failed ATTMF panel runs: `ATTMF_FAILED rc=...`.
Switched remaining panel `Input_Box` reads to `Validate(...)`, clearing static macro audit warnings.
Restored the QML capture-gaps empty-state binding to `gapsModel.filteredEmptyMessage`, restoring the full Python/QML test baseline.

Not Fully Closed

Fresh visible 12d panel proof is not closed by automation in this loop.

Evidence:

12d tester exists and worker-backed live control preflight passed.
The live macro evidence harness correctly classified `CSM_Apply_Profile.4dm` as a panel macro and returned `blocked_panel_macro`.
That harness only accepts no-panel data smoke macros, so it cannot prove the visible CSM panel shell.

Required next proof:

Open `exports/CSM_Apply_Profile.4do` in `C:\12d_auto\12dAITester`.
Capture a fresh visible screenshot or panel contract proof for the panel shell.
Confirm the visible panel shows the source box, client choice box, horizontal button rows, seeded group grid, selected review grids, project/runtime values grid, run evidence, and Go to element button.
Run one real Vida or UnityWater package through the panel path, not only through headless shims.

Verification Commands

python scripts\build_csm_knowledge_graph.py
python -m pytest -q
python _planning\run_export_audit_2026-05-29.py
python "C:\Users\a.almouhajer\OneDrive - Veris\0_IDEA\bible-assistant\scripts\compile_12d.py" "C:\Users\a.almouhajer\Veris\Veris DNA - General\01_Codelist\Client_Schema_Manager\exports\CSM_Apply_Profile.4dm"
python "C:\Veris_12d_Agent_Runtime\tools\twelve_d_index\audit_12d_macro_calls.py" "C:\Users\a.almouhajer\Veris\Veris DNA - General\01_Codelist\Client_Schema_Manager\exports\CSM_Apply_Profile.4dm"
$env:PYTHONPATH="C:\Veris_12d_Agent_Runtime\backend"; python -m veris_runtime.cli live-control-preflight --dismiss-safe-modals --timeout 90
$env:PYTHONPATH="C:\Veris_12d_Agent_Runtime\backend"; python -m veris_runtime.cli live-macro-evidence "C:\Users\a.almouhajer\Veris\Veris DNA - General\01_Codelist\Client_Schema_Manager\exports\CSM_Apply_Profile.4dm" "C:\12d_agent_runtime\results\csm_apply_profile_panel_attempt_20260620.txt" --timeout 45 --expected-status pass --required-key status

Evidence Paths

Live control preflight: `C:\12d_agent_runtime\evidence\live_control_preflight_20260620_225633_7fa450\summary.md`
Panel macro blocked proof: `C:\12d_agent_runtime\evidence\live_macro_CSM_Apply_Profile_20260620_230053_8c46ff\summary.json`
Export audit report: `.planning\EXPORT_AUDIT_2026-05-29_FINAL.md`